Plain English Summary
Background and study aims
Many women have a positive experience of birth, however some identify a gap between their expectations of birth and what happens. This mismatch has been linked with poor experience, distress and anxiety. Being well informed, having coping strategies and feeling in control during labour can enable a positive birth experience. Antenatal education is available. However, not all women attend the NHS classes and the content varies. As there is limited time to deliver this education, it is important that it is evidence-based, effective and efficient.
Who can participate?
To understand the current antenatal education, we will gather the opinions of women and staff about antenatal education.
To develop the intervention, we will invite women, their birth partners and staff from North Bristol NHS Trust, to take part in public patient involvement, alongside organisations advocating for women.
What does the study involve?
We will talk with patients about the current antenatal education at North Bristol NHS Trust
We will collaborate with women, birth-partners, organisations and staff to co-design a two hour antenatal education session and a short intervention to enable staff to support the coping strategies discussed in the session.
To understand antenatal education there will be 1-2 hour long focus groups with women and staff.
To test the intervention and compare it to standard care we will ask women to complete questionnaires before and after their session and 2 and 6 weeks after the birth of their baby. Birth partners will be asked to complete a questionnaire. We will ask staff to complete a questionnaire before and after attending a session, and one at 2 months.
What are the possible benefits and risks of participating?
Benefits of participating: Women, partners and staff will be participating in a study that may directly benefit their pregnancy experience. However, as the classes will only run in three of the community midwifery sites, it may be that women and partners are participating to benefit women in future.
Risks of participating: Women and staff will be asked to give their time. Women will be asked questions about their experience and levels of anxiety, depression and trauma. This may mean that women think about these issues more, or identify that they are struggling with them. As part of their clinical care team, we will take steps to support women if this happens.
Where is the study run from?
Southmead Hospital, Bristol, UK
When is the study starting and how long is it expected to run for?
July 2019 to August 2020
Who is funding the study?
1. Health Foundation
2. The David Telling Charitable Trust
Who is the main contact?
Dr Abi Merriel
Dr Abi Merriel
Population Health Sciences
University of Bristol
Department of Women's and Children's Health
Antenatal Care Education (ACE): The co-design and piloting of interventions to improve patient and staff experience through better birth preparedness
A co-designed antenatal and staff intervention can be implemented into practice and improve women’s experience.
Approved 19/06/2019, NHS HRA (South West - Frenchay Research Ethics Committee, Level 3, Block B
Whitefriars, Lewins Mead, Bristol, BS1 2NT; firstname.lastname@example.org; 0207 104 8210), ref: 19/SW/0073
Non-randomised; Both; Design type: Process of Care, Education or Self-Management, Psychological & Behavioural, Complex Intervention, Management of Care, Qualitative
Primary study design
Secondary study design
Patient information sheet
Not available in web format, please use the contact details below to request a patient information sheet
There are 5 parts to this study, which will enable us to build up a clear picture of antenatal education in the UK. The multiple designs have been selected carefully to ensure that we develop a detailed picture of what women want locally. Further to this, we will ensure that we situate the design of the final interventions in the national situation. The contact these work packages enable with other NHS organisations and stakeholders in antenatal education will try to ensure that we harness existing resources.
Work package 1: focus group sessions: women from antenatal classes
Work package 2: qualitative study of staff's perspectives of antenatal education
Work package 3: cognitive interviewing and testing of pilot tool for measuring expectations
Work package 4: controlled pilot study of antenatal education session for women
Work package 5: pilot study of intervention for staff
Focus Groups with Women (Work Package 1), Research and clinical staff on the research team from NBT and UoB at an NBT/Community site
Focus Groups with Staff (Work Package 2), Research and clinical staff on the research team from NBT and UoB at an NBT/Community site
Think Aloud Interviews with Women (Work Package 3), Research and clinical staff on the research team from NBT and UoB at an NBT/Community site; Expectations of birth questionnaire (Work Package 4), The women will complete a questionnaire on paper or online before the session and 1-2 weeks after the session.
Staff Intervention feedback (Work Package 5), Staff will be asked to complete a feedback form immediately following the intervention, in whichever clinical area the intervention takes place. A member of the study team will collect these responses.
Staff satisfaction with work scale (Work Package 5), Staff will be asked to complete the questionnaire twice either on paper prior to the session or online. They will then be asked to complete it again 2-3 months after the intervention.
Staff pilot intervention (Work Package 5), Staff will be invited to attend a brief intervention about coping strategies delivered at NBT in the clinical areas in which staff work. The intervention will be delivered by a member of the research team.
Feedback about sessions from women and birth partners (Work Package 4), We will ask women to complete the questionnaire immediately following the session which takes place at at an NBT/Community site
Clinical Information about delivery (Work Package 4), This will be collected from case notes by clinical members of the research team. However, for women who have their baby outside of NBT, we will phone the women at the same time as the follow up questionnaires and ask them for the information.
Outcome assessment (Work Package 4), This will be a paper, online or telephone completion of a questionnaire by the women whilst they are at home at 2 and 6 weeks postnatal.
Staff debrief (Work Package 4), Members of the research team will debrief community midwifery staff delivering the intervention using a structured debrief form at an NBT/Community site where the session has taken place
Staff delayed intervention feedback (Work Package 5), Staff will be asked to complete a feedback form 2-3 months following the intervention, either on paper or online.
Pilot or standard antenatal education intervention (Work Package 4), Community Midwives who will routinely deliver care, will deliver either their standard or the new intervention at an NBT/Community site
Primary outcome measure
The main outcome for the study will be the production and piloting of the interventions, there will be no primary outcome as the study is not powered to detect any differences, as it is pilot work.
Secondary outcome measures
For WP1 & 2 the outcomes will be an understanding of the current landscape of women's antenatal education, coping strategies and expectations.
For WP3 we will produce an expectations questionnaire.
For WP 4:
4.1 Number of women and partners attending the sessions
4.2 Immediate feedback on the intervention from women and partners
4.3 Delayed feedback on the utility of the intervention via a postnatal survey at 2 and 6 weeks.
4.4 Debrief with staff delivering the intervention for 10 minutes post intervention recorded on a structured form by a member of the research team.
4.5 Length of session delivered, as timed by the research team member
4.6 Content delivered as reported by the community midwife
4.7 Research team assessment of fidelity of intervention via audio-recording.
4.8 expectations of labour and birth questionnaire - change pre-post intervention
4.9 birth outcomes
4.10 2 and 6 weeks questionnaire to record the childbirth experience questionnaire, Edinburgh postnatal depression scale, the Generalised Anxiety Disorder Scale, and a PTSD Scale.
For WP 5:
5.1 Number of staff attending the intervention will be collected
5.2 Immediate feedback on the intervention from staff
5.3 Delayed feedback on the utility of the intervention via a survey at 2-3 months
5.4 All staff consenting to participate in the sessions will be asked to complete a satisfaction with work scale before the study and 3 months later
Overall trial start date
Overall trial end date
Reason abandoned (if study stopped)
Participant inclusion criteria
There are five work packages (WPs), with separate inclusion criteria:
WP1: Aged > 16, invited to attend/attended ANE Class in North Bristol NHS Trust (NBT)
WP2: Any clinical role, involved in labour/delivery care at NBT
WP3: Aged > 16, either antenatal or postnatal NBT patient
WP4: Women and partners attending ANE at NBT, willing to participate and can complete an english questionnaire
WP5: All clinical staff involved in labour and delivery care at NBT
Target number of participants
Planned Sample Size: 611; UK Sample Size: 611
Participant exclusion criteria
Does not meet inclusion criteria
Recruitment start date
Recruitment end date
Countries of recruitment
Trial participating centre
North Bristol NHS Trust Southmead Road Westbury-on-Trym
North Bristol NHS Trust
0117 41 49330
Health Foundation; Grant Codes: 1109133
Funding Body Type
Funding Body Subtype
The David Telling Charitable Trust
Funding Body Type
Funding Body Subtype
Results and Publications
Publication and dissemination plan
Planned publication in a high-impact peer-reviewed journal
IPD sharing statement:
All data generated or analysed during this study will be included in the subsequent results publication
Intention to publish date
Participant level data
Basic results (scientific)